The three-pass method
- 1
Pass one — five minutes, decide if it matters
Title, abstract, section headings, figures, conclusion. That's it. You are answering one question: is this paper relevant to me? Most papers die here, and they should. Being ruthless at this stage is the whole skill.
- 2
Pass two — an hour, understand the claim
Read the introduction and discussion properly. Look hard at the figures — in most papers the figures *are* the result and the prose is commentary. Skim the methods. You should now be able to say what they claim and roughly how they got there.
- 3
Pass three — only if you must reproduce or attack it
Now read the methods line by line, check the statistics, and try to find where it breaks. Reserve this for papers that matter — a handful per project, not per week.
Read the paper the authors didn't write
- What's the sample, really? Buried in the methods, and frequently much less impressive than the abstract implies.
- **What did they *not* measure?** Absences are where the weaknesses hide.
- How do the limitations they admit differ from the ones you can see? The gap between those two is often the most interesting thing in the paper.
- Does the conclusion actually follow from the result? Discussions routinely over-claim, and noticing it is exactly the critical faculty your degree is for.